Key Takeaways
- ✓What dealers call an extended warranty is a service contract. The FTC says these are optional products and can be expensive.
- ✓The FTC says prices can range from several hundred dollars to several thousand, and that a contract may duplicate the warranty that already comes with the car.
- ✓The CFPB says that, generally, you cannot be required to buy an extended warranty to get an auto loan.
What It Is: A Service Contract, Not a Warranty
The "extended warranty" offered in the finance office is a vehicle service contract. The FTC's used car buying guide defines it: "A service contract is a promise to perform (or pay for) certain repairs or services." Its guide to auto warranties and service contracts says such a contract "is not a warranty as defined by federal law, because you buy it separately."
The contract is often not the dealer's own. The FTC notes that "Many service contracts sold by dealers are handled by independent companies called administrators."
Is It Required or Optional?
It is optional. The FTC says: "Auto service contracts are optional products and can be expensive." The CFPB's answer on required products says "Generally you cannot be required to buy an extended warranty, GAP insurance, or credit insurance." The Minnesota Attorney General puts it this way: "A consumer does not need to buy a service contract or maintenance package to complete the purchase of an automobile."
If a dealer or lender says the product is required, the CFPB's suggestion is to "ask them to show you where your sales contract says it is required."
What Does It Cost?
The FTC gives the only range we could confirm: "Prices can range from several hundred dollars to several thousand." It adds that "You also may need to pay a deductible each time your vehicle is serviced or repaired." The price is not fixed. Minnesota's attorney general notes that "the prices of many optional products are negotiable."
Government records also show amounts on individual contracts. Each figure below is what a regulator says a specific dealer charged, or what a buyer told the FTC. They show what has appeared on real contracts. They are not typical prices.
- Single contracts in FTC cases, 2022 to 2024. FTC complaints describe service contract charges of $2,500, $3,398 and $3,755 at Leader Automotive Group, $3,687 at Lindsay Automotive Group and $3,937 at the Napleton dealerships. The complaint against the Rhinelander dealerships describes "a $2,500 vehicle service contract, which cost nearly 15% of the vehicle's purchase price."
- Two buyers in an FTC interview study. The FTC's January 2024 Federal Register notice cites one participant charged $1,950 and another who bought "a $2,000 service contract that the dealer falsely said was free".
- Bundles financed by one lender. In a November 2023 order against Toyota Motor Credit, the CFPB said of bundles that included vehicle service agreements, GAP and credit insurance: "The cost of the bundled products, financed by Toyota Motor Credit, averaged between $700 and $2,500 per loan."
What to Check Before You Decide
- Overlap with the factory warranty. The FTC warns that "an auto service contract might give you the same coverage you get with the warranty that already comes with the vehicle," and says to "compare it to the manufacturer's warranty that came with your car."
- What is left out. Per the FTC, service contracts "typically don't cover damage that may occur in an accident or normal wear and tear to the vehicle."
- Who stands behind it. Minnesota's attorney general says to "Make sure you understand exactly what company is behind your contract."
- The cancellation terms. The FTC's list of questions includes: "Is there a cancellation and refund policy for the service contract? Are there cancellation fees?"
How to Decline It or Take It Off
- Before you sign, ask whether the payment you were quoted includes a service contract, and what the payment is without it.
- If it is on the contract and you do not want it, say you are declining it and ask for the paperwork to be reprinted. The FTC's advice is to "tell the dealer to remove any add-ons you don't want."
- If you do want coverage, you do not have to decide in the finance office. The FTC notes that "you can buy most add-ons from independent retailers."
- After the sale, the CFPB says that for an optional add-on you added to the loan, "you have the right to cancel it during the term of the loan, which can save you money." Refund rules are set by the contract and by state. In Washington, for example, the attorney general says "If you cancel within the first ten days after purchase and you do not make a claim, you must receive a full refund." The add-on refund estimator gives a rough pro-rata figure from your own numbers.
Next Step: Check the Quote You Were Given
If a service contract is on a quote or buyer's order you already have, upload a photo of it to OTD Shield. It reads the document line by line and flags the charges to question before you sign. The first scan is free.
To see every common charge in one table, with which ones a state requires and which are optional, go to Is this dealer fee legit?
Sources
- FTC, Auto Warranties and Auto Service Contracts, April 2024
- FTC, Buying a Used Car From a Dealer, April 2024
- FTC consumer alert, Car dealerships can't charge you for add-ons you don't want, August 16, 2024
- CFPB, Am I required to purchase an extended warranty, GAP insurance, or credit insurance to get an auto loan?, March 5, 2024
- Minnesota Attorney General, Buying a Car: Optional Products
- Washington State Attorney General, Buying Precautions
- FTC and State of Illinois v. Leader Automotive Group, complaint (PDF), filed December 19, 2024
- FTC and State of Maryland v. Lindsay Automotive Group, complaint (PDF), filed December 27, 2024
- FTC and State of Illinois v. North American Automotive Services (Napleton), complaint (PDF), filed March 31, 2022
- FTC and State of Wisconsin v. Rhinelander Auto Center, complaint (PDF), filed October 24, 2023
- FTC, Combating Auto Retail Scams Trade Regulation Rule, Federal Register notice (89 FR 590), January 4, 2024
- CFPB press release, CFPB Orders Toyota Motor Credit to Pay $60 Million (archived), November 20, 2023
Each page was read on November 17, 2026. Rules differ by state and change over time. This page is information, not legal or tax advice.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I have to buy the extended warranty to get the loan or the car?
Generally no. The CFPB says that, generally, you cannot be required to buy an extended warranty, GAP insurance or credit insurance, and that in most situations they are optional. Minnesota's attorney general says a consumer does not need to buy a service contract or maintenance package to complete the purchase of an automobile.
How much does a dealer extended warranty cost?
The FTC says auto service contract prices can range from several hundred dollars to several thousand, and that you may also need to pay a deductible each time the vehicle is serviced or repaired. The price is set by the seller, and Minnesota's attorney general notes the prices of many optional products are negotiable.
Can I cancel a service contract after I sign?
The CFPB says that if an add-on product is optional and you add it to your loan, you have the right to cancel it during the term of the loan. The refund terms are in the contract and vary by state. The FTC suggests asking about the cancellation and refund policy, and any cancellation fees, before you buy.
More short answers are in the car buying FAQ, and every term is defined in the glossary.